In 1975, a single-story home in Tucson’s Catalina Foothills sold for $85,000. Today, that same property is valued at nearly $1.1 million — a reflection of both rising real estate prices and the exclusivity of the surrounding desert landscape. Over five decades, the house became more than an investment. It was the childhood home of Savannah Guthrie and the longtime residence of her mother, Nancy Guthrie. Now, the property has drawn national attention after authorities confirmed it is part of an active investigation into Nancy’s disappearance.
Originally built in 1969, the 3,776-square-foot residence sits on a full acre of Sonoran Desert terrain. The home includes five bedrooms and four-and-a-half bathrooms, with sweeping views typical of the Catalina Foothills neighborhood. Public property records show that Nancy briefly listed the house for sale in 2007 before deciding to keep it. For nearly 50 years, it remained the family’s anchor — a place tied to faith, tradition, and everyday memories. Savannah has often spoken about her upbringing in Tucson with pride, recalling Sunday services, family dinners, and simple outdoor moments that shaped her early life before she attended the University of Arizona and later built a national broadcasting career.
The home also carries deep personal history. Savannah’s father, Charles, passed away unexpectedly in 1988, a loss that profoundly affected the family. Nancy continued to live in the house, maintaining stability for her children during a difficult time. In interviews, Savannah has described her mother as the steady presence who held everything together. Just months before the recent events, Savannah returned to Tucson for a televised segment highlighting her hometown, sharing a warm lunch and laughter with her mother and sister. At the time, the visit felt like a celebration of roots and family.
Authorities have since confirmed that Nancy was last seen at the residence on the evening of January 30, 2026. The Pima County Sheriff’s Department stated that evidence at the property led investigators to treat the location as a crime scene. The normally quiet desert neighborhood — known for its dark night skies and limited street lighting — has been filled with deputies, media crews, and a growing display of support at the entrance. What was once a symbol of stability and cherished memories now stands at the center of a serious investigation, as the community continues to hope for answers.